Elephant Conservation, Outreach & Elephant Diseases
IEF is very excited to start a new interview segment in our eNewsletter, aiming to have conservationists explain their work in their own words. We hope to inspire and show what it takes to be on the front lines of elephant conservation. We are honored to have our inaugural interview with Dr. Michele Miller. She has extensively studied tuberculosis in elephants and her project Disease Risk Analyses for Tuberculosis Detection and Prevalence in Elephants was supported by IEF.
Question: Where did you study? How did you get started?
Dr. Miller: My graduate studies were completed at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, where I received a MSc and PhD in veterinary immunology and a DVM. This was followed by a post-doctoral fellowship at the San Diego Zoo Center for Reproduction of Endangered Species, investigating immune responses to various infectious diseases of wildlife. This training along with practical experience as a zoo veterinary clinician has provided a broad base for my current research.
Question: What first inspired you to focus your research on elephants?
Dr. Miller: I’ve always been fascinated with elephants since a child. Once I became a zoo veterinarian, I had the opportunity to work closely with these species and developed a life-long commitment to improving our knowledge to provide better welfare for human-managed animals and conserve wild populations.
Question: When and where did you first see an elephant in person? How did it affect you?
Dr. Miller: As a young child, my family would take me to the Milwaukee Zoo. I was enthralled watching the elephants and decided I would become a veterinarian working with wildlife. I also remember the annual circus parade in which the elephants walked down the street – their massive size and magnificent presence left a lasting impression.
Question: How important is it for the public to experience elephants in person and be inspired to care?
Dr. Miller: I think that it is very important for the public to have the opportunity to experience elephants in person. Being in the presence of elephants stimulates multiple senses – visual, olfactory, and auditory experiences that create a more complete awareness of elephants than can be provided by media such as television. Watching their complex behavior gives insight into the important role elephants play in their environment and help inspire people to learn more and become involved in conserving these species.
Question: What do you wish was more widely known about elephants?
Dr. Miller: Elephants are subject to many of the same health issues that confront other long-lived species such as humans. For instance, degenerative joint disease occurs more frequently in older elephants, just as in us as we age. Elephants are also susceptible to a variety of infectious diseases, including TB and a type of elephant herpesvirus.
Question: What misconception about elephants would you like to correct?
Dr. Miller: Elephants have very complex social interactions, which we are still learning about. They communicate through touch, smell, sound, and visual cues. It is important for their welfare that we provide adequate space and opportunity for elephants to interact with each other, whether it is in managed care or the wild.
Question: How can in-situ and ex-situ conservation work hand-in-hand?
Dr. Miller: We can learn and study animals in both the wild and managed care to understand the biology and behavior of these species. Ex-situ conservation activities can provide insight into nutritional needs, disease issues, and techniques for handling, transport, and other management, that might take much longer and be logistically more difficult to determine in wild populations. However, the information we gather from in-situ conservation creates a valuable knowledge that can improve the welfare of managed elephants. The conservation work done in-situ and ex-situ should be synergistic.
Question: How would you explain elephant TB to someone who has no experience in elephant management?
Dr. Miller: TB in elephants can be caused by the same bacteria that cause TB in humans and cattle. Most cases of elephant TB are the human form. Like humans, it is a very slow chronic disease and many elephants can be infected for years without showing any outward signs. TB can be diagnosed by taking samples from the trunk, similar to how humans are sampled (sputum), although the bacteria may not always be present even if an individual is infected. Therefore, it is important to improve our knowledge and tools for detecting TB at earlier stages so that we can prevent development of disease in the affected animal as well as minimize the risk of transmission to other animals and people.
Question: Is elephant TB treatable or curable?
Dr. Miller: Elephant TB can be treated with a course of drugs for human TB. Some of the challenges are that the drugs need to be given over a prolonged period of time (up to a year or more) and they can cause side-effects which may delay completion of treatment. Whether TB is cured or not, is difficult to determine, even in humans. Since we are unable to take chest x-rays of elephants or determine changes in disease, we don’t have good measures of how effective treatment is. However, our experience has shown that the treatment can stop the secretion of bacteria which is a risk to other animals and important in managing this disease.
Question: Can humans contract TB from elephants? If so, under what circumstances?
Dr. Miller: Although it is possible, there are no documented cases of a person getting the disease from an elephant. Under rare circumstances, people who are in close contact with elephants (such as handlers) have been shown to have a positive skin test (this is a test of exposure to the bacteria but doesn’t necessarily mean that a person has disease). Similar to TB in people, we believe that causal contact with elephants (such as at a zoo) presents a very low risk. It is probably more likely that you would get infected from other humans than elephants.
Question: How does elephant TB affect elephant conservation work? The future of elephants?
Dr. Miller: TB, like any disease issue, can impact conservation directly through loss of valuable individuals as well as indirectly through potential regulatory restrictions on movement of animals for translocation. There is incomplete understanding of the impact of this disease in both ex-situ and in-situ populations. Since this slow disease is difficult to detect even in elephants under managed care, we may not truly understand the potential impact on elephants into the future.
Question: Is there anything else you’d like to add?
Dr. Miller: The International Elephant Foundation recognizes the importance of understanding the role of disease in conservation. Through this support, we have been able to gather information that will improve our knowledge of TB in elephants and create a foundation for measuring our progress into the future
Jumbo thanks to
Michele Miller, DVM, MPH, Ph.D.
Professor, South African Research Chair in Animal TB
DST/NRF Centre of Excellence for Biomedical Tuberculosis Research
MRC Centre for TB Research
Division of Molecular Biology and Human Genetics
Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences
Cape Town, South Africa
Michele Miller, DVM, MS, MPH, Ph.D., is staff veterinarian of wildlife medicine at the Rare Species Conservatory Foundation,. Specializing in immunology, infectious diseases and interaction with the environment. Conservation projects include desert pronghorn (Mexico), and pygmy hippo (West Africa). Current in situ projects focus on elephant and rhino issues in Africa, as well as tuberculosis issues in New World primates, elephants, large cats, wild ungulates and other captive and free-ranging wildlife.
Interview reprinted courtesy of the National Elephant Herpesvirus Laboratory at Smithsonian’s National Zoo and the Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute.
Question: HOW DID YOU GET INVOLVED IN EEHV RESEARCH?
I first developed an interest in viruses and DNA as a teenager, which led me to experiment with agarose gel electrophoresis for separating bacteriophage DNA molecules of different sizes for my PhD thesis research. I published the first restriction cleavage patterns of human herpes simplex virus genomes in 1975. During a more than 45 year career in DNA research focused mostly on the molecular biology of the many different types of human herpesviruses, I always also had an interest in conservation issues as well as virus evolution and published the complete genome sequence of chimpanzee cytomegalovirus in 2004. Naturally then when Laura Richman first told me that she thought Kumari had died of a previously unknown herpesvirus infection I jumped at the chance to study the problem, including inviting her to come and do her PhD studies on EEHV in my laboratory at Johns Hopkins.
Question: WHAT ARE YOUR ONGOING RESEARCH PROJECTS?
Together with our close collaborators in Paul Ling’s group in Houston we have just assembled the complete 200,000-bp complete genome sequence of EEHV4, the fourth type of Asian elephant Proboscivirus and the first of the GC-rich branch to be so characterized. There has also been major progress in characterizing the most divergent genes from numerous distinct EEHV1 strains directly from pathological samples collected by a concerned consortium of veterinarians and our other collaborators from all around the world. We also keep hoping to get a breakthrough in our attempts to culture and propagate these viruses from clinical samples in laboratory cell culture, and we continue efforts to generate multiple clones for expressing enough antigens from each of the sequenced EEHV species in yeast to develop a robust multiplex serology chip assay that may finally overcome the major problems of antibody cross- reactions between them.
Question: BIGGEST CHALLENGE FOR EEHV RESEARCH?
Understanding why 20% of Asian elephant calves worldwide are susceptible to life-threatening acute hemorrhagic disease when undergoing primary infection with EEHV1 (or sometimes other EEHV types), whereas African elephants which harbor just as many types of EEHV species of their own hardly ever get disease. Other than our very successful virus hunting and diagnostic DNA tests that have identified clinical samples suitable for extensive genetic characterization there is little hope of significant further progress in understanding or combating this devastating disease without a major influx of new research funding. Whilst I still ran an active well-funded research laboratory studying human herpesvirus disease it was easy to borrow expertise and a little bit of time and effort from my postdoctoral fellows to clone and express EEHV genes, or carry out IFA and IHC assays or develop specific rabbit antibodies for example, but that is no longer the case, and the number of hands-on laboratory personnel involved have now dwindled down from five or six to just three and dropping. Furthermore, both Virginia Pearson (our collaborator on African elephant herpesvirus identification) and I have been working extensively essentially as unpaid volunteers for several years now. The International Elephant Foundation, the Morris Animal Foundation and a Collections Stewardship Leadership grant from the IMLS have contributed essential funding that has kept our EEHV research projects limping along, but my group will have to totally close down within a year or so without the kind of generous funding from a private donor that currently supports the EEHV research in Paul Ling’s laboratory at Baylor College of Medicine in Houston.
Question: WHERE DO YOU SEE EEHV PREVENTION, DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT IN FIVE YEARS?
No real change. There is at present virtually nothing known about the immunology of the elephant hosts themselves or of this novel new group of mammalian herpesviruses. Without cell culture and lots of funding, there is also really no realistic hope of vaccines within the near future, and it is only the ability to carry out close blood test DNA monitoring of calves and to respond to “viremic” illness with rapid good medical care that has improved the management of the disease in the USA in recent years. But it has been a major financial challenge just to keep the dedicated expertise necessary for this in Erin Latimer’s NEHL diagnostic laboratory, as well as in my molecular genetic strain subtyping group, together from one year to the next, let alone get serious about any more extensive efforts at finding better anti-EEHV drugs or exploring the mechanisms of EEHV pathogenesis.